Lord Beecham – 2015 Parliamentary Question to the Ministry of Justice

The below Parliamentary question was asked by Lord Beecham on 2015-02-11.

To ask Her Majesty’s Government what is the justification for the Ministry of Justice’s refusal to permit visits to any prisons by a reporter from The Guardian.

Lord Faulks

The External Communications team at the Ministry of Justice receives a significant number of requests by local and national media for access to prisons. For operational reasons and resource implications it is not possible to facilitate all requests.

Each request is considered on its own merit, with careful thought over the subject area, resource and security implications, victim impact, and value to the taxpayer. In a similar way to the police or the NHS, there are operational considerations to be made when filming or reporting in prisons. When facilitating media access we must ensure that the needs of victims are met, which may involve concealing identities, carrying out relevant checks and liaising directly with victims about the access request. We must also ensure that media access does not breach any security restrictions, for example filming keys or locks. Consideration is also given to protecting the identities of prisoners and staff.

We are committed to providing open and transparent access to prison and regularly provide access to journalists for news items, features and documentary programmes. We aim to provide a range of access to different journalists covering both print and broadcast media, local, national and online media.

Since the beginning of January 2015 we have provided access to a range of media outlets, a few examples are listed below:

• The Guardian were given access to HMP New Hall – http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/jan/30/new-hall-womens-prison-inmates-equals
• BBC and the Sun were giving access to HMP Coldingley
• Regional BBC were giving access to HMP Northumberland (Sodexo run prison)
• Telegraph and Heart Radio were giving access to HMP Drake Hall
• Evening Standard and regional BBC were giving access to HMP Thameside (Serco run prison)
• BBC Radio 4 were giving access to HMP Prescoed/HMP Cardiff
• Sky Sports were giving access to HMP Feltham
• National BBC, regional ITV and the Manchester Evening News were giving access to HMP Styal
• Evening Standard and London Live were giving access to HMP Isis
• East Anglia Daily Times and regional BBC radio were giving access to HMP Hollesley Bay
• Sky News were given access to HMP Ranby
• ITV were given access to HMP Norwich